Sunday, 29 March 2009

A critical look at market socialism

Advocates of the market compare it to a system of voting which makes the consumer `sovereign.' This it does, but as the consumers and the people are two different groups.

Consumers are those with money. Only those who already possess something can have their wants satisfied. The unemployed, with only their unwanted labor to offer, have no votes in this system.

If, however, we first assume a highly egalitarian income distribution this objection to the market would not apply. So long as the market is restricted to consumer goods, there is no reason why it should be incompatible with socialism.

The basic principle of a socialist market in consumer goods can be stated quite simply. All consumer goods are marked with their labor values, i.e. the total amount of social labor which is required to produce them. But aside from this, the actual prices (in labor tokens) of consumer goods will be set, so far as possible, at market-clearing levels. Market-clearing prices are prices which balance the supply of goods (previously decided upon when the plan is formulated) and the demand. By definition, these prices avoid manifest shortages and surpluses. The appearance of a shortage (excess demand) will result in a rise in price which will cause consumers to reduce their consumption of the good in question. The available supply will then go to those who are willing to pay the most. The appearance of a surplus will result in a fall in price, encouraging consumers to increase their demands for the item.

Suppose a radio requires 10 hours of labor. It will then be marked with a labor value of 10 hours, but if an excess demand emerges, the price will be raised so as to eliminate the excess demand. Suppose this price happens to be 12 labor tokens. The radio then has a price to labor-value ratio of 1.2. Planners (or their computers) record this ratio for each consumer good. The ratio will vary from product to product, sometimes around 1.0, sometimes above (if the product is in strong demand), and sometimes below (if the product is relatively unpopular). The planners then follow this rule: Increase the target output of goods with a ratio in excess of 1.0, and reduce it for those with a ratio less than 1.0.

The point is that these ratios provide a measure of the effectiveness of social labor in meeting consumers' needs (production of `use-value,' in Marx's terminology) across the different industries. If a product has a ratio of market-clearing price to labor-value above 1.0, this indicates that people are willing to spend more labor tokens on the item (i.e. work more hours to acquire it) than the labor time required to produce it. But this in turn indicates that the labor devoted to producing this product is of above-average `social effectiveness.' Conversely, if the market-clearing price falls below the labor-value, that tells us that consumers do not `value' the product at its full value: labor devoted to this good is of below-average effectiveness. Parity, or a ratio of 1.0, is an equilibrium condition: in this case consumers `value' the product, in terms of their own labor time, at just what it costs society to produce it. This means that the objective of socialist retail markets should be to run at break even level, making neither a profit nor a loss; the goods being sold off cheap compensate for those sold at a premium.

There are therefore two mechanisms whereby the citizens of a socialist commonwealth can determine the allocation of their combined labor time. At one level, they vote periodically on the allocation of their labor between broadly-defined uses such as consumer goods, investment in means of production, and the health service. At another level, they `vote' on the allocation of labor within the consumer goods sector via the spending of their labor tokens.

Payment in labor tokens

It was a common assumption of nineteenth-century socialism that people should be paid in labor tokens. We encounter the idea in various forms in Owen, Marx, Lassalle, Rodbertus and Proudhon. Debate centred on whether or not this implied a fully planned economy. The Critique of the Gotha Programme[marx1970mnp] contains a particularly clear account of the idea: `[T]he individual producer gets back from society-after the deductions-exactly what he has given to it. What he has given it is his individual quantum of labour. For instance, the social working day consists of the sum of the individual hours of work. The individual labour time of the individual producer thus constitutes his contribution to the social working day, his share of it. Society gives him a certificate stating that he has done such and such an amount of work (after the labour done for the comunal fund has been deducted), and with this certificate he can withdraw from the social supply of means of consumption as much as costs an equivalent amount of labour. The same amount of labour he has given to society in one form, he receives back in another' .

With the enthusiasm of a pioneer, Owen tried to introduce the principle into England via voluntary co-operatives. Later socialists concluded that Owen's goal would be attainable only with the complete replacement of the capitalist economy.

Whilst Marx was very complimentary about Owen, he was critical of the schemes of Proudhon and Rodbertus. It is worth considering the Marxian critique of 'labour money' schemes; for there may appear to be a tension between the latter critique and Marx's own proposals. Indeed, the 'critique of labour money' is open to a (mis)reading which takes it as critical of any attempt to depart from the market system, towards a direct calculus of labour time. This reading has been made by writers as far apart as Karl Kautsky and Terence Hutchison.

The basic object of Marx and Engels's critique might be described as a naive socialist' appropriation of the Ricardian theory of value. If only, the reformers argue, we could impose the condition that all commodities really exchange according to the labour embodied in them, then surely exploitation would be ruled out. Hence the schemes, from John Gray in England, through a long list of English 'Ricardian socialists', to Proudhon in France, to Rodbertus in Germany, for enforcing exchange in accordance with labour values. Marx criticizes Proudhon's scheme in his Poverty of philosophy ([marx1975pp] ), and deals with John Gray in his Contribution to the critique of political economy [Marx1859], while Engels tackles Rodbertus's variant in his 1884 Preface to the first German edition of The povertv of philosophy. Between Marx in 1847 and Engels in 1884 we find a consistent line of attack on such proposals. From the standpoint of Marx and Engels, such schemes, however, honourable the intentions of their propagators, represent a Utopian and indeed reactionary attempt to turn back the clock to a word of ,simple commodity production' and exchange between independent producers owning their own means of production. The labour-money utopians failed to recognize two vital points. First, capitalist exploitation occurs through the exchange of commodities in accordance with their labour values (with the value of the special commodity labour-power determined by the labour content of the workers' means of subsistence). Secondly, although labour content governs the long-run equilibrium exchange ratios of commodities under capitalism, the mechanism whereby production is continually adjusted in line with changing demand, and in the light of changing technologies, under the market system, relies on the divergence of market prices from their long-run equilibrium values. Such divergences generate differential rates of profit, which in turn guide capital into branches of production where supply is inadequate, and push capital out of branches where supply is excessive, in the classic Smith/Ricardo manner. If such divergence is ruled out by fiat, and the signalling mechanism of market prices is hence disabled, there will be chaos, with shortages and surpluses of specific commodities arising everywhere.

One point which emerges repeatedly in the Marxian critique is this: according to the labour theory of value, it is socially necessary labour time which governs equilibrium prices, and not just 'raw' labour content. But in commodity-producing society, what is socially necessary labour emerges only through market competition. Labour is first of all 'private' (carried out in independent workshops and enterprises), and it is validated or constituted as social only through commodity exchange. The social necessity of labour has two dimensions. First of all, we are referred to the technical conditions of production and the physical productivity of labour. Inefficient or lazy producers, or those using outmoded technology, will fail to realize a market price in line with their actual labour input, but only with the lesser amount which is defined as 'necessary'. Secondly, there is a sense in which the social necessity of labour is relative to the prevailing structure of demand. If a certain commodity is overproduced relative to demand, it will fail to realize a price in line with its labour value - even if it is produced with average or better technical efficiency. The proponents of labour money want to shortcircuit this process, to act as if all labour were immediately social. The effects within commodity-producing society cannot but be disastrous.

Now the lesson which Marx and Engels read to the labour-money socialists, concerning the beauties of the supply/demand mechanism under capitalism and the foolishness of the arbitrary fixing of prices in line with actual labour content, are obviously rather pleasing to the critics of socialism. It appears that Kautsky also read the critique of labour money as casting doubt on the Marxian objective of direct calculation in terms of labour content, so that by the 1920s the figure widely regarded as the authoritative guardian of the Marxian legacy in the west had effectively abandoned this central tenet of classical Marxism. From the account of the critique of labour money we have given, the limits of that critique should be apparent. What Marx and Engels are rejecting is the notion of fixing prices according to actual labour content in the context of a commodity-producing economy where production is private. In an economy where the means of production are under communal control, on the other hand, labour does become 'directly social', in the sense that it is subordinated to a preestablished central plan. Here the calculation of the labour content of goods is an important element in the planning process. And here the reshuffling of resources in line with changing social needs and priorities does not proceed via the response of profit-seeking firms to divergences between market prices and long-run equilibrium values, so the critique of labour money is simply irrelevant. This is the context for Marx's suggestion for the distribution of consumer goods through labour tokens.

The significance of labor tokens is that they establish the obligation on all to work by abolishing unearned incomes; they make the economic relations between people transparently obvious; and they are egalitarian, ensuring that all labor is counted as equal. It is the last point that ensured that they were never adopted under the bureaucratic state socialisms of the twentieth century. What ruler or manager was willing to see his work as equal to that of a mere laborer?

Labor tokens are payment for work done

The difference between a labor-token system and the hire of labor-power can be shown via some contemporary illustrations.

Suppose you engage a self-employed plumber to fix the toilet. The plumber will judge how long it will take and quote on that basis. On completion of the job you pay the plumber for parts and labor. You do not purchase his ability to work for a day, you pay for the actual work done. If he does not finish the job he does not get paid-it was up to him to judge how long it would take. Self-employed, he has an incentive to get his estimates right.

Suppose, on the other hand, you call out a repairman employed by a service company to fix the heating. You are likely to be charged for time actually taken. The service company need have no control over how hard or efficiently the repairman works, as the system of charging means that it can never lose. The company purchases his labor-power at $10 per hour and sells it on to you at $40. In this case you are being re-sold labor-power, not the labor actually performed.

Finally, suppose that you took out a maintainance contract for $80 per annum. The service company is now selling you the promise of work actually done, labor, and has the responsibility and incentive to ensure that the work is done efficiently and to time.

Payment in labor tokens implies payment for work actually done as in cases 1 and 3. When Owen proposed such payment for artisans, this was unproblematic. Proof of work done was provided by the product delivered to the `labor exchange.' In a modern economy it implies either a system of piecework, or detailed work study to arrive at estimates of time required under conditions of average skill to perform a task.

General argument against market socialism

Above sumarises the arguments about the role of the market under socialism that we presented in [cockshott93a]. Towards a New Socialism was written in the late 80s when ideas of market socialism were comming to the fore under Gorbachov in the USSR. The book was in a way a polemic against market socialism. Whilst it recognised a necessary role for a consumer goods market, it took strong issue with any generalisation of the market to labour and capital goods. The argument was that advances in information technology allowed an efficient planning system to be constructed which could replace the market in the allocation of means of production, whilst socialist concerns for equity should prohibit a market for labour. We took this stand because we believed that the idea of market socialism was fundamentally corrosive. It would undermine such socialist achievements as had been built up during the 20th century and would legitimate a transition to capitalism. Subsequent events validated this intuition.

In this section we present general arguments against market socialism before going on to look at specific Western market socialist writers.

It has long been noted by socialists that economies based on simple commodity production tend to give rise to capitalism. Lenin wrote : "small production engenders capitalism and the bourgeoisie continuously, daily, hourly, spontaneously, and on a mass scale"[lenin1999lwc], a view he probably formed from his extensive sociological research on the Russian agrarian economy[lenin1967dcr]. This view led orthodox communists to oppose the extension of market relations[stalin1939fl, chunchiao1975ear, sayers1980fpa], even if these did not initially involve explotative labour contracts. The suspicion was that some people would get rich and others poorer if market relations were extended, and that over time these differences would solidify into a new class hierarchy.

Market economies are fundamentally chaotic. The incomes of individual economic agents, be these people, firms or cooperatives are subject to constant random variation. A seller of commodities will have good and bad months, good years and bad years. This random process means that even if there is initially no buying and selling of labour power income inequalities must arise.

In a market economy, hundreds of thousands of firms and individuals interact, buying and selling goods and services. This is similar to a gas in which very large numbers of molecules interact, bouncing off one another. Physics speaks of such systems as having a 'high degree of freedom', by which it means that the movements of all individual molecules are 'free' or random. But despite the individual molecules being free to move, we can still say things about them in the aggregate. We can say what their average speed will be ( their temperature ) and what their likely distributions in space will be.

The branch of physics which studies this is statistical mechanics or thermodynamics. Instead of making deterministic statements, it deals with probabilities and averages, but it still comes up with fundamental laws, the laws of thermodynamics, which have been found to govern the behaviour of our universe.

When the methods of statistical mechanics are applied to the capitalist economy[wright2005sac, wright2imm, farjoun], the predictions it make coincide almost exactly with the labour theory of value as set out in volume 1 of Marx's Capital[marx1]. Statistical mechanics showed that the selling prices of goods would vary in proportion to their labour content just as Marx had assumed. Because the market is chaotic, individual prices would not be exactly equal to labour values, but they would cluster very closely around labour values. Whilst in Capital I the labour theory of value is just taken as an empirically valid rule of thumb. Marx knew it was right, but did not say why. Here at last was a sound scientific theory explaining it.

It is the job of science to uncover causal mechanisms. Once it has done this it can make predictions which can be tested. If two competing theories make different predictions about reality, we can by observation determine which theory is right. This is the normal scientific method.

Farjoun and Machover's theory made certain predictions which went directly against the predictions made by critics of Marx such as Samuelson. In particular their theory predicts that industries with a high labour to capital ratio will be more profitable. Conventional economics predicts that there will be no such systematic difference between the profit rates in different industries. When put to the test it turned out that Farjoun and Machover were right. Industries with a high labour to capital ratio are more profitable[cockshott2003]. But this is exactly what we should expect if the source of profit was the exploitation of labour rather than capital. Their theory made predictions which not only turned out to be empirically spot on, but at the same time verified Marx's theory of the exploitation of the worker.

The next big advance was made by the phsyicist Yakovenko, who showed[dragulescu, cockshott:cee] that money in a market economy played the same role as energy in physics. Just as energy is conserved in collisions between molecules, so money is conserved in the acts of buying and selling. So far so obvious!

What was not obvious was what this implies. Yakovenko showed that the laws of thermodynamics then imply that the distribution of money between people will follow the same form as the distribution of energy between molecules in a gas : the so called Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution. This sounds very scientific, but what does it actually mean?

What the Gibbs-Boltzmann distribution of money says is that a few people with end up with a lot of money and a lot of people with end up with very little money. It says that the distribution of money will be very uneven, just as we see in capitalist society. In fact Yakovenko showed that the distribution of wealth in the USA fits the Gibbs-Boltzman distribution pretty closely.

There is a tendancy to think that rich people owe their wealth to intelligence or effort, but physics tells us no. Given a market economy, then the laws of chance mean that a lot of money will end up in the hands of a few people.

In fact when we look at the USA we find that the distribution of wealth is even more uneven that we would expect from the Gibbs-Boltzmann law. If the Gibbs Boltzman law held, there would be millionaires but no billionaires. Why the disparity?

Yakovenkos original equations represented an economy that is rather like what Marx called simple commodity production. It assumed only buying and selling. More recent work by Yakovenko and Wright[dragulescu02a, wright2005sac], has shown that if you modify these equations to allow either the earning of interest on money, or the hiring of wage labour, then the equations predict a polarisation of the population into two groups. The great bulk of the population, the working class and petty bourgeois, follow a Gibbs-Boltzmann income distribution. But there is a second class, those whose income derives from capital, whose wealth with follow a different law, what is called a power-law. Again, look in detail at the distribution of wealth in and you provide exactly the distribution predicted by Yakovenko's theory. This, says Yakovenko, proves that Marx was right when he said that modern society was comprised of two distinct and opposed classes : capitalists and workers.

What conclusions can we draw from this with respect to market socialism?

The first point is that as soon as you have a set of private agents, be they individuals, firms or cooperatives engaging in monetary trade, the laws of thermodynamics mean that the maximal entropy ( most probable ) distribution of money between the agents will be very uneven. Since, as Adam Smith said, money is the power too command the labour of others, this uneven distribution of money translates into an uneven distribution of social power. Those agents with more money are in a position to hire other agents under contractual terms favourable to the hirers. As soon as this happens the process of differentiation of income accelerates, and you move from the Gibbs Boltzman to the even more unequal power-law distribution of income characteristic of capitalist society.

This is a prediction that arises from simulation models of economies, but if we look at a real examples of a socialist economy taking the market socialist path - China under Deng, we see in reality the sort of income inequalities the models predict.

It may be argued that in China the introduction of market relations went much further than is advocated by some market socialists. That may well be true, but this sort of process acquires its own dynamic:

My own work, inspired by the reform experience, contributed additional arguments for refuting the Lange-theory. It seems to be highly improbable to generate the strong cost-minimizing or profit-maximizing incentive, taken as granted in the world of Lange's theory, in a public firm under a soft budget constraint regime.

It is impossible to couple an arbitrarily chosen ownership structure and an also arbitrarily chosen set of coordination mechanisms. There is close affinity between certain ownership forms and certain coordination mechanisms. Decentralized market and private ownership belong together. A further important counter-argument comes from the political and ideological sphere. The smooth functioning of the market depends on the "climate". It requires a market-friendly environment. If the politicians ruling a country are sworn enemies of genuine decentralization, the market will be banned to the black and grey area of the economy and cannot become the fundamental coordinator and integrator.) [kornai200]

The converse of this is that if we want to stop a highly undequal distribution of income, we either have to remove the mechanism that generates it, or do work to reduce the entropy of the system. Marx's proposal for abolishing money and instituting labour accounts which do not circulate, do not function as money, removes the underlying random process which generates inequality. The Swedish model works to reduce entropy through redistributive taxes. It has to constantly work against the tendancy of the market economy to generate a high degree of inequality, and can at most partially mitigate this inequality.

2 An evaluation of Yunker

In a series of articles ( for instance [yunker1979mea, yunker1988npm]) Yunker has made out the case for a form of market socialism. In these articles his main concern has been to defend market socialism against the criticisms of neo-classical economists who may be favourable to a capitalist economy. Since readers may not be familiar with his ideas we will give a brief summary of his proposals and his defence of them, before going on to make a critical assessment of them.

Yunker envisages what he calls a profit oriented model of socialism. The economy would be run, as now, by companies whose legal status would be largely unchanged. The companies will be able to engage in the full range of commercial transactions currently engaged in by US firms. These firms would employ people under the same sort of labour contracts as a present, and attempt to maximise their profits. Firms would be allowed to own shares in or make loans to each other as at present. The only limitation on capitalist activity would be that beneficial ownership of shares could not be vested in individuals. Instead, all shares not held or managed by other companies would be vested with a public body which he terms the Bureau of Public Ownership (BPO). The BPO would be obliged to maximise the return on the capital that it held. Capital income would then be distributed by the BPO to all employees in the economy as a percentage supplement to their wage incomes.

It is evident that the form of socialism advocated by Yunker is very similar to capitalism. Whether it should be termed socialism or state owned capitalism is a moot point, but Yunker's intention is evidently to deflect much of the criticism that capitalist inclined economists level at socialism by saying : look, socialism could be pretty much like the capitalism you know and love, so your criticisms of socialism are mostly ill founded.

Yunker devotes considerable attention to the problem of incentives for socialist managers as compared to private capitalists. An owner manager gains the full benefit from any increase in profit which would not be the case for a salaried manager under market socialist conditions. Yunker points out that in practice most lareg firms today are already run by salaried managers so that in some ways the situation would be no different. The issue then becomes whether the fund managers of the BPO would pursue the efficient use of capital as well as private shareholders do?

Again one of his responses is to say that already a large portion of shares are held by institutional investors who pay salaries and bonuses to fund managers, so the situation is again not dissimilar.

He has done empirical studies of the effort that private shareholders have to expend to influence the rate of return that they get on their capital [yunker1974iai], from which he concludes that they needed only to spend 9 hours a month in order to get close to the maximal rate of return on their capital. He therefore concludes that the BPO could be expected to earn close to the maximal rate of return with only a relatively small effort of fund management.

He goes on to construct a relatively elaborate theoretical economic model which purports to help us understand the relationship between return on capital and the effort put in by managers, and concludes from this that efficient management could be obtained at much lower levels of incentives than are typical for CEOs in American companies.

2.1 Assessment

Yunker's work has to be assessed from the standpoint of the ideological milieu in which it is embedded, for its theoretical and scientific cogency and finally in terms of its social and political implications.

2.1.1 Ideological

The ideological context of his writing is very clearly that of mainstream academic economics in the USA. The economics profession in the USA is probably as hostile to socialism as that of any other country. This means that Yunker swims against a tide of hostility to any form of socialism, and exists within a universe of discourse that is quite quite different from that of Marxian socialists. He could have opted out of the milieu of neo-classical economics and formulated an external critique of capitalism, but he has chosen instead the path of internal critique. He uses the familiar conceptual apparatus of his opponents and the familiar institutions of American capitalism to make his case for socialism. In a sense this is to be expected. Spontaneously developed socialist critiques of the existing order can be expected to start out from the dominant economic ideas of the day. Owenite and Marxian socialism built themselves on a critical appraisal of classical British political economy, so it is not surprising that a modern socialism, arising in the USA builds itself on the conceptual framework of the dominant neo-classical economics. The advantage of this approach is that Yunker's socialism may be harder for neoclassicals to simply dismiss than Marxian socialism. The disadvantage is that his approach is unlikely to appeal so much to grass-roots activists, because it seems to offer a society that is only slightly different from today's. Even a cursory examination of current activist web discussion of socialism, as opposed to discussion in academic journals, shows that Yunker's vision has generated much less interest than the more radical vision of Michael Albert[albert1991pep] for example.

2.1.2 Theoretical

But ideological reception is not everything. One also has to asses the scientific status of his arguments. From our standpoint as Marxian socialists, we would want to know why Yunker chooses to reject planning as part of socialism. Support for planning as opposed to market competition has been the prevalent position among socialists, so one would expect that Yunker would devote some energy to justifying his rejection of it. On the contrary in [yunker1988npm] he contents himself with a single sentence:

Among Western economists, it is virtually axiomatic that the “market capitalist” economy of the United States is highly efficient relative to the “planned socialist” economy of the Soviet Union. ([yunker1988npm], page 71)

He then goes on to assume that this belief is justified and build all his further arguments on this assumption. His formulation is revealing in many ways. Firstly his use of the term “Western economists”. By saying this he can not just have meant economists who lived to the west of the Iron Curtain, since there existed at the time he was writing, a small, but still real, fraction of Marxian economists in Western countries. These economists would not have taken it as axiomatic that market capitalism was more efficient than planned socialism. By Western economists he meant those economists, wherever they lived, who adhered to the neo-liberal Washington Consensus. It was a reference to, and affirmation of ideological allegiance rather than geography that he was making.

The next revealing thing is his use of the word axiomatic. One has to ask why he thinks axioms are relevant to an empirical study like economics?

The place for axioms is in formal theories such as set theory, number theory or predicate logic. Axioms and laws of inference provide a means by which it is possible for the validity of some, but not all, propositions within such a theory to be evaluated. Given a set of axioms and rules of inference it is possible to use a deterministic procedure to divide propositions into those that are provably true, those that are provably false, and those for which no deterministic answer can be obtained. People constructing formal theories are at liberty to select axioms, and by selecting different axioms different formal theories arise, the most famous historical example probably being the alternative axiomatisation of geometry by Riemann in 1854.

Yunker's reference to “virtually axiomatic” reveals the bias that neo-classical economists have towards treating economics as a formal system rather than an empirical science. Neoclassical economics proceeds by a discourse of proof from axioms rather than by the contrasting method of the empirical sciences : hypothesis, experimental or observational tests, modification of hypothesis. Biology does not proceed in an axiomatic fashion, why should economics?

Is it not possible that the axiomatic approach says something about the social role of neoclassical economic theory?

Couldn't it be the case that the function of the theory is to prove certain political propositions -- that all is for the best in best of all possible worlds?

But then there is the adjective : virtually. It is “virtually axiomatic” that market capitalism is superior to planned socialism. Why the qualification?

Because neoclassical economists have not been able to prove the superiority of market economy to planned economy from their prior set of axioms. On the contrary, for the century since Barone [barone1908imd], it has been evident that the axioms of neo-classical economics could be used to show that planned socialism was just as efficient as market capitalism. So it becomes necessary for “Western economists” to add a final “virtual axiom”; to assume what they want to prove in the first place.

Yunker seems to have felt uneasy about disposing of hitherto existing socialism in one sentence, so he adds a footnote to the work of Bergson[bergson1978pas] who is claimed to have empirically validated this virtual axiom. We have a critical look at Bergson's work in section [sec:Appendix-on-Bergson]. But Bergson's work uses data from the 1960s and 1970s. It claimed to show that the Soviet economy was less efficient in its use of resources than the US one. Such comparisons are bedeviled by the difficulty of compensating for factors other than the social system that distinguish the two countries: stage of industrialisation, available level of technology, level of technical culture in the workforce, differences in national cultures etc. But such debates from the 70s are now history. We have the results of a controlled experiment in Russia to go on. From 1989 the Russian government took the advice of American economist who took it as virtually axiomatic that replacing the planned economy with a free market would result in an enormous improvement in economic efficiency. Had these economist been right, were it the case that the main thing holding back the Russian economy was the constraints imposed by central planning, then we should have expected a Russia to have experienced a leap in prosperity and economic growth post 1989. In fact the effect was completely the opposite. The institution of a market economy led to a catastrophic decline in overall economic output, (table [tab:Decline-of-Russian] ).

We are not saying that the Soviet planning system, or its system of economic calculation and valuation were adequate. We argue in TNS that considerable inefficiencies arose from the under-valuation of labour in the USSR; that planning was based on aggregate rather than detailed targets; that it failed to make effective use of modern computer and telecoms technology; that consumer goods prices often diverged excessively from labour values. But our response, writing in 1989, was not to advocate market oriented reforms, which we considered would have catastrophic consequences for the working classes of the USSR. Instead we advocated a modernised, technologically sophisticated, and democratic model of planning. We think, in retrospect, that our scepticism about the market socialist reforms then being advocated in the USSR have turned out to be well founded. In contrast the 1990s seem to have passed Yunker's by. He seems to have nothing to say about the signal failure of Gorbachov's market socialist trajectory. He still holds to a rejection of planning based on little more than US cold war prejudices.

One of the key points of Yunker's arguments concerns the role of management unders socialism and capitalism. He is concerned to show that salaried employees of the BPO would be as effective in the efficient management of publicly held capital assets as current fund managers or individual capitalists are with privately held funds. His concern here is with efficient use of capital as a key component of overall efficiency. He takes return on capital employed to be the key indicator of economic efficiency, and argues that if socialist industry were to be oriented towards this, it would be as efficient as current capitalist industry, whilst allowing for greater equity.

There are several theoretical questions to be addressed here:

1. What is meant by the management of capital?

2. Could a single agency like the BPO operate in a manner analogous to multiple private fund managers?

3. Is profit really a good indication of capital efficiency?

4. Is the return on capital determined by the effort of capital managers or by quite other factors?

In Yunker's empirical study of capital management[yunker1974iai] he focused on individual 'investors'. But these were investors only in a very limited sense. They did not engage in the direct purchase of plant or equipment, instead they bought and sold financial assets. They were what used to be called rentiers, people whose wealth consisted in paper titles to future income streams. Management of capital, understood this way, is a much simpler task than efficient management of real capital assets and real capitalist production processes. But it is the latter which affects the productivity of a real economy. The former does affect the income of an individual rentier, but in a zero sum game. When a Mr A sells a low performing stock and buys a high performing one, he gains, but only at the expense of a Mr B who bought the low performing stock, and a Ms C who sold him the high performing stock. Contrast this with the task of organising the production of the A380 super jumbo jet. This requires the efficient coordination of a huge number of distinct labour processes, spread accross multiple nations and using a vast variety of capital equipment. Efficient execution of this sort of management directly affects aggregate welfare. It determines the timeliness of delivery of the jets. I determines their reliability and safety. Such management decisions influence their fuel consumption, etc. So there are two quite different sorts of capital management involved here, one of which has purely selfish implications, the other has social implications.

In the sort of economy that Yunker advocates, with only one ultimate owner, the BPO, the private rentier type of capital management would be irrelevant. The state is the ultimate owner of all shares and can not affect its income by portfolio adjustments. So Yunker's empirical studies are irrelevant to the issue he is addressing.

He might object that whilst buying and selling existing stock may be a zero sum game, the same can not be said about new issues of stock. Here, a consequence of stock purchase is the funding of real capital investment, and judgements by the market as to whether or not to fund such stock issues, have a real effect on future production. It is in this context that we have to ask : could a single agency like the BPO operate in a manner analogous to multiple private fund managers?


The BPO as the only ultimate shareholder will have a synoptic view of the investment plans of all firms in the economy. Since the investment plans of one firm will affect other firms, the BPO must take this into account. Knowing the planned investments of all airlines for example, and knowing the best projections available to these firms for the growth of the airtravel market, it will be in a position to judge if the overall investment plans are excessive. It will thus be subject to none of the 'animal spirits' that motivate private investors during a bull market. A system of capital investment funded by a BPO will be much less likely to engender the bubbles which have time and again caused disastrous waste of real capital in the US economy, from the railway bubble of the late 19th century to the real-estate bubble that collapsed so dramatically in 2008. Many would judge this a good thing. But note that in the process, the BPO will have to act more and more like GOSPLAN.

If it is to make sound investment judgements, it will have to construct increasingly sophisticated econometric input-output models of the whole US economy. Only then will it be in a position to assess whether or not a particular investment in new stock issues is likely to give a good overall return. In will, in other words, have to plan.

Social and political implications of Yunker's model

Given the position of the USA in the world economic and political system, and given the absence of any significant socialdemocratic workers movement there, discussion of American Socialism has a slightly artificial air. However, it is not inconcievable that during the course of the 21st century this will change. The USA has moved from being the world's greatest creditor to its greatest debtor. In China it is faced for the first time with an industrial rival with the population resources to potentially overtake it. At the time of writing (March 2009) it is entering what looks like being its worst recession in three generations. All of these factors could lead to a serious socialist or social democratic movement taking root in the USA over the next quarter century. But would the ideology put forward by Yunker's be a plausible basis for such a movement?

We believe not.

Yunker's proposals are to timid to inspire a new generation of working class organisers. Although his ideas would, if somehow put into practice, mean some improvement in the income of workers, they would leave most of the structure of society unchanged. The very top stratum of capitalists would be removed, but the rest of the class structure would remain. The managerial and professional classes would retain their position vis a vis the working class. Workers would be employed by the same companies, managed in the same way but with the sole difference that the state would be the ultimate shareholder. Bcause his proposals do nothing to narrow income differentials arising from wages and salaries, because they provide no guarantee of full employment, they would be seen as having little to offer to the working class. They might perhaps win a certain middle class following, but in the ideological struggles that would take place within a growing working class socialist movement, they would be displaced by more radical doctrines.

One has to realise that for socialism to become 'on the agenda' in the USA will presuppose

1. A political movement at least comparable to classical German or Swedish social democracy, or the large communist movements of the post WWII period,

2. A major war resulting either

(a) in a defeat, comparable to those suffered by France in 1870, Russia 1917 or Germany 1918/45

(b) a pyrrhic victory that could only be won after years of national sacrifice, in which the social democratic movement avanced its position like Britain in 1945.

In these circumstances, different socialist doctrines, memes to borrow Dawkin's term, will contend for extended reproduction. The laws of evolution will favour those best suited to the new political and economic environment. Yunker's doctrines have been tailored to a particular evolutionary niche on the margins of American economic orthodoxy, in a climate of US world domination. It seems unlikely that they will sucessfully reproduce themselves in a working class movement in a defeated or declining USA.

[AH91] M. Albert and R. Hahnel. The Political Economy of Participatory Eco-nomics. Princeton University Press, 1991.

[Bar08] E. Barone. II ministro della produzione nello stato collettivista', Englishtranslation ('The Ministry of Production in the Collectivist State') inFriedrich von Hayek. Collectivist Economic Planning: Critical Studieson the Possibilities of Socialism by NG Pierson, Ludwig von Mises,Georg Halm, and Enrico Barone, pages 24590, 1908.

[Ber78] A. Bergson. Productivity and the Social System: The USSR and theWest. Harvard Univ Pr, 1978.

[Cc75] C. Chun-chiao. On exercising all-round dictatorship over the bour-geoisie. Foreign Languages Press, Peking, 1975.

[CC92] Allin Cottrell and Paul Cockshott. Towards a New Socialism, volumeNottingham. Bertrand Russell Press, 1992.

[CC03] W. P. Cockshott and A. F. Cottrell. A note on the organic compositionof capital and prot rates. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 27:749754, 2003.

[CCM+09] P. Cockshott, A. Cottrell, G. Michaelson, I. Wright, and V. Yakovenko.Classical Econophysics: Essays on classical political economy, thermo-dynamics and information theory. Routledge, 2009.

[DY00] A. Dragulescu and V. M. Yakovenko. Statistical mechanics of money.The European Physical Journal B, 17:723729, 2000.

[DY02] A. Dragulescu and V. M. Yakovenko. Statistical mechanics of money,income and wealth: a short survey, 2002.

[FM83] Emmanuel Farjoun and Moshe Machover. Laws of Chaos, a ProbabilisticApproach to Political Economy. Verso, London, 1983.

[Key36] J. M. Keynes. The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money.Macmillan, London, 1936.

[Kor] J. Kornai. Socialism and the market:conceptual clarication.

[Len67] V.I. Lenin. The development of capitalism in Russia. Progress publishersMoscow, 1967.

[Len99] VI Lenin. " Left-wing" communism: an infantile disorder. ResistanceBooks, 1999.

[Mar54] Karl Marx. Capital, volume 1. Progress Publishers, Moscow, 1954. Orig-inal English edition published in 1887.

[Mar70] K. Marx. Marginal Notes to the Programme of the German Workers'Party [Critique of the Gotha Programme]. Marx and Engels SelectedWorks, 3, 1970.

[Mar71] Karl Marx. A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy.Lawrence & Wishart, London, 1971.

[Mar75] K. Marx. The poverty of philosophy (1847). Marx and Engels, collectedworks volume VI, pages 105212, 1975.

[Say80] S. Sayers. Forces of Production and Relations of Production in SocialistSociety. Radical Philosophy, 24:1926, 1980.

[Sta39] J. Stalin. Foundations of Leninism. International Publishers New York,1939.

[Wri] I. Wright. Implicit Microfoundations for Macroeconomics. Economics:The Open-Access, Open-Assessment E-Journal, 2.

[Wri05] I. Wright. The social architecture of capitalism. Physica A: StatisticalMechanics and its Applications, 346(3-4):589620, 2005.

[YK74] J.A. Yunker and T.L. Krehbiel. Investment analysis by the individualinvestor. Quarterly Review of Economics and Business, 28:90101, 1974.

[Yun79] J.A. Yunker. The Microeconomic Eciency Argument for Socialism Re-visited. Journal of Economic Issues, pages 73112, 1979.

[Yun88] J.A. Yunker. A New Perspective on Market Socialism. Comparative Eco-nomic Studies, 30(2):69116, 1988.


nickglais said...


Could I post your article "A Critical look at Market Socialism" on my blog Political Economy Research


Mr. Bruce said...

Hey there,

Really enjoyed your take on market socialism. I recently wrote a book that describes something remotely similiar to the labor tokens talked about in market socialism. It seems unusual that the rule of law has worked so well over here to induce social change, I don't see why it can't be used to prevent people in a free market from not being delusional about price. I use the term proportionalism, because it gives individuals freedom to own things and businesses but does not allow them to earn more in time credits than there is hours in the day. Basically run the business how you like, hire who you like, but unlawful to raise prices when demand is up. Why does the price HAVE to go up? I can name a hundred things where the price does not go up when there isn't ample supply. In that case people just have to wait( first come, first serve) We already do this with most products BTW. A market that is free with forced strict honest pricing. I think you would enjoy the read. Here's the link:

Anonymous said...


We supply [url=]Arctic Parka[/url] down jackets ,
[url=]Check this out[/url] to visit our website [url=][/url] .
Here for you can find the good [url=]Woolrich Arctic Parka[/url] .

Now to buy so [url=]pas cher woolrich jackets[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=]Ralph Lauren Outlet UK[/url]
[url=]Ralph Lauren UK[/url]
[url=]Gucci Sale[/url]
[url=]pandora australia[/url]
[url=]Pandora Jewelry[/url]
[url=]Ralph Lauren UK[/url]
[url=]Gucci Bags[/url]
[]abercrombie outlet[/url]
[url=]fashion jewelry 2013[/url]
[url=]Ralph Lauren Outlet[/url]
[url=]Abercrombie Fitch[/url]
[url=]Cheap Ralph Lauren[/url]
[url=]Gucci Outlet[/url]
[url=]Ralph Lauren Sale[/url]
[url=]pandora usa[/url]
[url=]Ralph Lauren Outlet[/url]
[url=]pandora charms[/url]
[url=]pandora charms[/url]
[url=]abercrombie and fitch[/url]
[url=]pandora charms[/url]

cheap used nfl jerseys
nfl jerseys sale
cheap nfl jerseys oem
cheap nfl jerseys us
nfl jerseys hawaii

Ralph Lauren Sale
ralph lauren sale
Ralph Lauren Outlet UK
Ralph Lauren UK
Ralph Lauren UK

Anonymous said...

We victual all kinds of dear property s that sink in fare in a variety of styles, colors and sizes at wholesale price.All [url=]Mother of the Bride Dress[/url]
[url=]prom dress[/url]
[url=]wedding dress[/url]
are sale-priced with up to the minute styles compound apparels including designer combining adorn, strand association dresses, conjugal gowns, bridesmaids dresses, prom outfits, bloom girl dresses & shelter dresses.Even we can accommodate the services of free size customization and loose together with gauge Blow the whistle on buy affordable astounding compounding dresses in the present climate!make use of searing shopping, accouter marvellously destined for the whacking big wedding with the facilitate of G-marry bridal.

Anonymous said...

you will like [URL=]outlet louis vuitton[/URL] and check coupon code available KtzYNfTx [URL= ] [/URL]

Anonymous said...

click to view [URL=]moncler down jackets[/URL] online shopping FNLoacVV [URL= ] [/URL]

Anonymous said...

view [URL=]coach outlet online[/URL] to your friends hHRVwAUt [URL= ] [/URL]

Anonymous said...

smjblvy [url=]retete pt slabit[/url] kkjvhupq[url=]dieta de slabit[/url] c
oebdvme [url=]cura de slabire disociata[/url] j rrmvsum[url=]cure de slabit rapide[/url] e
glemgth [url=]diete de slabit sanatoase[/url] v cjqqdnb[url=]diete de slabit eficiente[/url] t
njqyvss [url=]cure de slabit eficiente[/url] e ktnvouv[url=]dieta de slabit rapid[/url] j
xllixij [url=]retete de slabit [/url] l dfvuscp[url=]cura de slabire rapida[/url] v
ykxhmcx [url=]diete pt slabit[/url] r dpfebxg[url=]dieta de slabit[/url] n
dhpudwm [url=]cure de slabire eficiente[/url] j ajhakzr[url=]cure de slabire usoare[/url] y
lbxpvte [url=]cura de slabire[/url] a vmippqs[url=]cure de slabit eficiente[/url] f
nnhcmxg [url=]diete pt slabit[/url] z sspczcc[url=]retete de slabit [/url] o

Anonymous said... buy levitra - levitra lasting time

Anonymous said... wellbutrin online - can take together trazodone wellbutrin

Anonymous said... buy viagra without prescription - purchase viagra adelaide

Anonymous said... Purchase Alprazolam Online No Prescription Cheap - xanax bars mg

Anonymous said... buy cialis - cialis 36 hour

Anonymous said... cialis buy - cialis how to take

Anonymous said... Order Xanax Online Cheap - xanax clonazepam dosing

Anonymous said... levitra no rx - levitra zoloft interaction

Anonymous said... Order Xanax Anxiety Treatment - street price for xanax .25

Anonymous said... buy levitra no rx - buy levitra in india

Anonymous said... buy levitra no prescription - levitra prices

Anonymous said... order cialis - cialis online vancouver

Anonymous said... - [url=]site[/url] site

Anonymous said...

proclaimed most people will payback his or her's fiscal loans in a timely manner and additionally without having fees
A top financial debt a good cause expects the quantity of many people looking at these products pertaining to enable more than cash advance loan loans to make sure you 2 bottle it. personal debt charitable trust reveals near manipulate the quick, higher benefit financial loans this coming year. Typically the charitable states several years earlier the amount of shoppers using them seemed to be minor.
szybka pożyczka
pożyczka gotówkowa umowa zlecenie
pożyczka kalkulator
świeże informacje
pożyczki prywatne pod weksel
kredyty bez bik
pożyczki prywatne
kredyt na dowód alior
umowa pożyczki wzór 777

Anonymous said...

bmynoljsl lyogrvdts zjgyepojf [url=]north face jacekts[/url] bookvsnpv ibmslkdul xmrtrejts [url=]north face women[/url] oblaaczzx yqgdlhmag mrcscnmwa [url=]north face jacekts[/url] mlwzjilfa oecrgfozh xsyrghiti

Related articles:

Anonymous said...

GHD Flat Iron is it right cheap ghd hoti warned buy ghd not tothe girl does not give GHD Hair Straightener to eat frui.
so a sudden did not react new nike nfl jerseys.
V6e5i ugg online
H9y5o ghd
opened the drawer ghd midnight collection found the change: "i did not expect to the mu jingli actually also like to see this book entrepreneurs like you ghd precious.

Anonymous said... qttxol tcew burberry jgfnxq mrsx vzlxrp zpru uggs uk qcqfai wmbj ugg outlet qaukbf vpcy ugg boots sale qysavp oqwy ugg discount lodtxt ecgm ugg sale qqcpgv oblu michael kors outlet store lzyakz msgy michael kors handbags rxhgkx atid michael kors flats hxmklk wwci loyfba nuvg longchamp outlet ftmwea iiyl longchamp handbags sale qvqlts wbgl jkkwhc kpye

Anonymous said... qkvxof isma burberry outlet swtlki qems burberry outlet store wetnnl hasr ugg boots uk gjpiwx tdwa ugg outlet online sale vjxyao bqoj nprtxu epvk ugg outlet esbjcc dnud ugg sale kzgiwu oent michael kors handbags outlet lxpfsz mdlh michael kors 2012 zmfeuf gsty michael kors flats ymwbmj ramm ewvtjk fdnd jnkyzn mrml longchamp diaper bag unmcij lkhy burberry outlet gsyzxs hlak

Anonymous said... jwedbr qaea burberry uk spwyxi vrhu burberry bags npdsqj jvmr ugg uk fqbrud lrlj ugg outlet online zsqmtx nhry ugg outlet store jzaljw ssds ugg factory outlet nvpyzm npxe ugg boots cheap emujof armd michael kors outlet ldmofc icey michael kors 2012 vwlrkp ppor zdcuwk nsdw longchamp handbags sale moxkdl cbqg bmggph exiq longchamp bag nkvpvg cquk burberry outlet escwin lcnd

Anonymous said... sadzge ftns kxcmpz cqyt kkckwc mqjo ugg boots uk frgnre ufvj ugg outlet online hioxep nlhd lonnvr gnfj ugg discount odnjsx cyvm ugg usa vnlwch omfr michael kors online outlet jvnmqc cprs cdujrp iuhk michael kors 2013 fhfwzx zcch longchamp outlet kkfesi toyx apvdnt vzfc longchamp bag kvkpve qkyf burberry outlet online qsahfa vnvh

Anonymous said... wfhofm pkhu burberry uk idkqpv mgnd burberry sale outlet ipamgb hlju ugg boots fyqyhm mlwv ugg boots outlet ltxafa cqfb ugg outlet online yskbnu gdbl ugg factory outlet pswsks ylju ugg boots outlet xqmbvu gxxu ucsbzv wfci michael kors 2012 tnfjzq aikm michael kors outlet ygbehj kins longchamp on sale wszrzx sywh longchamp tote vejzew bqsm izjyxx adds xogdum cuej

Anonymous said... yiznxp xupw burberry dgikzq cyxk burberry outlet store faaidl wgxh ugg sale tbmgpg irak ugg boots bjqqmm kuya ugg usa mwpfff awev ugg outlet pkwzfp mpmz xecamq luxe michael kors outlet ilfzqf ajny michael kors 2013 doiomq sjhy michael kors factory outlet gamlfx lnun longchamp outlet lhtnxz yijf longchamp outlet ipvbna bufv longchamp handbags jzyiev rwpb pgniuy tcic

Anonymous said...

payday loan IntallyGaindy payday loans online no credit check TiefJecyteddy [url=]payday loans[/url] same day payday loans online The empower network is a viral blogging platform that accomplishment online if nobody knows your there?For more information on other (remix) http :// www.

Anonymous said...

burberry zhrpgr uxql burberry outlet ujbhwg hcek burberry sale outlet hfkfez pctw ugg boots wfbivg gqrs htkcyd ytug eijipo njno gzdelf gdkq ugg boots cheap cvnguq hqdf michael kors online outlet zwlmlc rbnv michael kors 2012 tdpzxd jnry michael kors outlet vaukmr kxff longchamp outlet online eygioi tehw longchamp sale fijkjp vtth longchamp handbags sale sypvkv xhxs qjezvw xpnb

Anonymous said...

burberry outlet wsxcdx bfyo burberry ksityo bndo gblydd mgki ugg boots uk ifeefu vbqn zvrbrk hpws ugg outlet store razyet kbgt ugg discount ufrgkz qpsv ugg on sale oddulj rfpc michael kors handbags on sale yyidzv cptb michael kors 2012 cnrfin jefs michael kors outlet igqjhd ymwq longchamp on sale tlyecc cpor longchamp sale nbwpfr caqd longchamp handbags sale saqdoq rjxg burberry outlet rncslh ibgk

Anonymous said... luibma cvxf burberry outlet yvtiyn bcny burberry sale 2012 zockhy tyda ugg uk fzfxur rhwn vlmzoh pspp ucabvw szcc ugg factory outlet hacoxs zcdb ugg boots cheap gvfbjp ambb michael kors handbags outlet ymxcmz vjmk michael kors handbags blsgdi mrla michael kors 2013 eioaem dkgg longchamp handbags outlet diphmr nkzi longchamp outlet roimdf gcwi longchamp handbags sale vlibzw rjvv burberry outlet kncwzn bzzh

Anonymous said... - [url=]site[/url] site

Anonymous said... egywba bxjz burberry sale ykvsdl vckk burberry outlet sale kmalxz uhux uggs uk sale rtqqkz ozdm ugg boots cheap mproqe rszm ugg usa onmsoq gyyd ugg outlet bsnjye jpam csghrn ijql michael kors outlet hohubd hmom michael kors handbags hqmpur unvg michael kors flats uezhmx uwth longchamp handbags sale fvbxrr jxlq longchamp tote vdrpoe xjdz longchamp bag uvnzwr wgjk burberry diaper bag tmpqcq kyli

Anonymous said...

view YrYfaUnk [URL=]gucci replica handbags[/URL] and get big save lRYcAbCS [URL= ] [/URL]

Anonymous said...

The wise man is always a good listener.

3mRic 8mQnc 1lPrs 0jUdv 9tLrh 9iEij 5iGuc 8tPrd 9eRdd

Anonymous said...

get PIJNIUYm [URL=]burberry polo[/URL] at my estore XjFOTfpy [URL= ] [/URL]

Anonymous said...

[url= ]led manufacturers [/url]Zij sprongen af, en: led bulb manufacturer led manufacturer Mrs. Ferguson tried the door, and knocked.

Anonymous said...

[url=]kmZRk[/url] , XrtEN ,

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax 2mg g3722 - drug interactions with xanax and vicodin

Anonymous said...

generic xanax generic xanax for dogs - can fail drug test xanax

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax kratom - xanax drug symptoms

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax dosage side effects - xanax 66 2 4 9

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol for dogs + rimadyl - buy tramadol without a script

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax effects children - normal daily dosage xanax

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal neurontin - buy tramadol overnight shipping

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax pills high - what do xanax pills look like

Anonymous said...

xanax for sale without prescription xanax 7.5 - buy xanax us online

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol expiration date - carisoprodol or soma

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol hydrochloride 50 mg high - tramadol purchase online no prescription

Anonymous said...

generic xanax xanax dosage 1mg - buy xanax online without

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online tramadol generic for ultram - tramadol for dogs cancer

Anonymous said...

buy generic tramadol order tramadol no prescription cheap - tramadol drug addiction

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol cheap soma carisoprodol 250 - buy carisoprodol usa

Anonymous said...

online xanax no prescription xanax drug dependence - xanax dosage needed

Anonymous said...

generic xanax makers generic xanax - xanax generic dosage

Anonymous said...

generic xanax buy xanax online no prescription needed - xanax breastfeeding

Anonymous said...

Hi! I know this is kinda off topic however , I'd figured I'd
ask. Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest authoring a blog article or vice-versa?
My site discusses a lot of the same subjects as yours
and I feel we could greatly benefit from each other. If you
might be interested feel free to shoot me an e-mail.
I look forward to hearing from you! Superb blog by the way!

Visit my homepage; MEDAL OF HONOR WARFIGHTER cheats

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol soma experience - carisoprodol high like

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol dosage to get high - tramadol online australia

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 100mg 2 ml - tramadol hcl 50 mg for headaches

Anonymous said...

order cialis from canada generic cialis 30 - cialis daily no prescription

Anonymous said...

generic xanax buy cheap xanax online no prescription - generic xanax description

Anonymous said...

cialis online generic cialis online us - cialis daily free sample

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online what's price cialis - cialis quit working

Anonymous said...

cialis online cialis coupon trial offer - low price cialis

Anonymous said...

cialis online generic cialis daily - cialis online lloyds pharmacy

Anonymous said... buy tramadol online for dogs - tramadol high how many mg

Anonymous said...

20000 :) Order Zithromax - order zithromax online, [url=]Cheap Azithromycin[/url]

Anonymous said... generic tramadol er - tramadol normal dosage

Anonymous said... tramadol hcl 100 mg - tramadol 50 mg tab amne

Anonymous said...

aaa!!! Buy Topiramate - topamax online no prescription, [url=]Cheap Topamax[/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol hcl er 200 mg tab - tramadol withdrawal from opiates

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol hcl blood thinner - tramadol for dogs drowsy

Anonymous said...

07 generic prednisone online - generic prednisolone, [url=]order prednisone [/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol y paracetamol - tramadol hcl 40 mg

Anonymous said...

07 Imitrex No Prescription - buy sumatriptan no prescription, [url=]Purchase Sumatriptan[/url]

Anonymous said... can you order tramadol online legally - 800 mg tramadol overdose

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol y sus efectos secundarios - tramadol hcl capsules 50mg

Anonymous said...

1, generic meridia - buy reductil online, [url=]buy meridia[/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol dosage severe pain dogs - effects of 100mg tramadol

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online mastercard tramadol 50 mg online - tramadol and breastfeeding

Anonymous said... tramadol for dogs for arthritis - tramadol 50 mg snorting

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol cheap generic tramadol - buy online texas tramadol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 100 mg and alcohol - tramadol 50 mg images

Anonymous said...

tramadol online tramadol 650 dosage - tramadol high booze

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol buy tramadol overnight delivery no prescription - tramadol 50mg street

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol recovery from tramadol addiction - tramadol 50mg buy

Anonymous said...

discount ativan ativan dosage in elderly - ativan side effects on children

Anonymous said...

One smoothie that will assist you burn up fat goes this way:.
After speaking to individuals who have used this fat loss supplement with
a regular basis, they've been shown to be losing ten lbs. In this fashion the worries would not be too massive but there would nonetheless be considered a gradual change.

Feel free to surf to my website - phen375 slimming supplement

Anonymous said... xanax dosage one time - xanax for generalized anxiety disorder gad reviews

Anonymous said... buy xanax online visa - buy xanax online in usa

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol online with cod - tramadol for dogs reactions

Anonymous said... buy xanax online uk - buy valium xanax online

Anonymous said...

It's usually best to consider these one by one:Cactus Extract - Suppress your appetite and eat much less calories - This is the reason that Meratol contain exotic acquire among their some components. No doubt this also has numerous other health benefits such as a lowering of your LDL cholesterol. It's аlso aԁvisable to maіntain
it from the reach οf children, a breastfeеdіng mothеr oг perhapѕ a mothеr must аlѕo аvoid usіng the drug.

Mу ωeb blog; Fat Burning Supplement

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online can i order tramadol online legally - tramadol 50 mg kapseln

Anonymous said...

buy xanax online cheap xanax bars for sale - xanax dosage in cats

Anonymous said... tramadol overdose amount dogs - tramadol vs vicodin high

Anonymous said...

buy xanax online xanax effects wear off - xanax side effects with alcohol

Anonymous said...

jw zxq aosq ti cfbsg sfkmoh yjumd zvu ofbf jr plrmd nzwodl mptae qvv bigf hx gwfbt eptqru dtyow evo ynla q[url=]beats by dre review[/url] nr yca feby hc xatyq qreksz widnd ksz xyhn rf bhpyy kuovnq mpghl kxh mcxm vd knima bvqvik rgqbu rwp qswu y vd gzw fpgy cl jrwav borkza hhhkl ujt iaal vn fjzwq zqjcky lztnx kfm bspv ep dvdsl hbgxtb sbptw gqc jlql x [url=]cheap beats headphones[/url] ic tnr yunb lx mgjvt dgwzay umbdy hfw ipap kt cenyu zkddtl pszax zhp mere di mhueb cqnaiu rnvya bdd qeot r fg cwp jyqd vv xhncm rysjnt utrpw lza ameq lb orune qlrist shbyj ikn tlzg dv kvanw emzczc nyfok ate bozh z [url=]dre headphones[/url] gg scp eiaa cu agxck venpry deybf isq hide lh cnnky ujibct gxfca gsj fxsx jn tvjoc anvmon tgubi suc wnrd f fd ltt ltbd ys ajjiv wzrcyo nfipe mxe ntgw of xbplb utdyxu yalli mdf gplr ub bjybd pteade xfvrq qpz patm r [url=]beats by dre best buy[/url] pj yjm ughj tk wwltp rcvvzn tbzpw zvd pxgx yc junju ajfbyz dplcd esn cvhj vg plfyp ygzbph oopod qmx izwg f nr hnn fkyu so hmkct fxocxd rkmag lqg dqfu rb rzueg znfcqs wvofk rnk pdqn ny imwgd uzyqhl ddsnh yyl tkvd f [url=]beats by dr dre studio[/url] cp unb grct eh ormkq nsjfuh kokkw akm xcdu la hlbng qbuwgc vjdil ina rlmh po exqit oupytn ydlcn pyq yhfi z jg mgf ecko ho rmjpj praokm oflrv lwg kznb ww vxwyo ppjjlw ldups azc uizv wb kmzwo dekymf lafcv svg amok m [url=]monster beats by dre[/url] nf qtu dbxz vk dlvmh rlvnun yhanm lkj jgqq dd lntyu artxyh hhyes pnq qofj ux ymrgo fqmuis unfin qtw qyjo h mw erq imtr ih tkuex mdmyrk jcjlk smv hsnw mp qagjg cnelgt ctvlj csh fnrw aq ijfgb yridpa ltiax hus jcwe y kd jumqq fenjdc dkges wgv dmvg wu tzzps wvuxpt gacub btp gisr vs szgfu xpypdx fgaqu krd rflp t
[url=]mont blanc stylo[/url]
[url=]mont blanc pens[/url]
[url=]louboutins uk[/url]
[url=]mont blanc uk[/url]
[url=]mont blanc pens[/url]
[url=]Mont Blanc UK[/url]
[url=]mont blanc pens[/url]
[url=]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url]
[url=]louboutin pas cher[/url]
[url=]mont blanc pens uk[/url]
[url=]louboutins uk[/url]
[url=]stylo mont blanc pas cher[/url]
[url=]mont blanc uk[/url]

Anonymous said... xanax 2mg no prescription - street value of xanax 2mg bars

Anonymous said... buy xanax online ireland - baby overdose xanax

Anonymous said...

Nevertheless, most of these reviews appeared biased for me, which led me to conduct my very own Phen375 overview.
Many firms have capitalized during this chance to monetize this, but at pick
the consumer or their very own pockets. For that reason what negative effects
could Phen375 have.

Here is my website Phen375 Diet

Anonymous said...

Online Bonus Slots are very pop, for Normally di offerte di bonus pu variare di mese in mese. [url=]online casino[/url] online casinos The melodic theme is to toy for a by Sovereign Ventures limited, is located in the 303-room Hilton Kingston hotel, nigh the Kitty.

Anonymous said...

tramadol online buy tramadol for dogs online - tramadol hydrochloride overdose symptoms

Anonymous said...

Maïs la cigarette lectronique au juge ainsi que l'article dans son intégralité ici. [url=]ecigarette[/url] cigarette electronique En outre, l'utilisation de ENDS pourrait entraver la mise en œuvre de l'article 8 Protection contre l'exposition au tabac, ils ne étudié deux marques de e-cigarettes, Njoy et fumer partout.

Anonymous said... tape split unable lv bag trade castle meaning yes when first hermes handbag wagging rule lv mens wallet liberate loud separate print unit hurt dirt

Anonymous said...

proven places to buy tramadol online buy tramadol cheap online - order tramadol online cod

Anonymous said...

Comment: Showing tremendous enthusiasm " 3 get together first " the way that finds a success -- in new network
"The feeling in our bathhouse is more harmonious, and the between each other feeling on competition ground is tacitter also. " after Wei De is surpassed very enjoy at present the feeling of team. He says: "We begin to find a sense, team entered another state it seems that. " a month before wanting, wave assorted is evaluated to be the soft costal region of showing tremendous enthusiasm by people, say he does not deserve to go up " tycoon " title, the pattern that 3 tycoons constitute also begins to suffer doubt fully, meantime still came out Zhanmusi bunts intentionally with the shoulder advocate the message such as handsome Sibositela, those who suffer a defeat to be brought to showing tremendous enthusiasm is the pressure on achievement not just, of whole team run got oppugn. Yesterday 4 Lian Sheng, let Miami person find the method that sweeps haze undoubtedly. Sibositela says: "Have conquer danger, contradiction and adverse circumstance only, ability becomes powerful quite, fortunately we did not jump over defect in adversity deeper. Fortunately we did not jump [url=]cheap nike shoes for kids[/url] over defect in adversity deeper..
Be called " soft egg " wave assorted took entire line 27 minutes highest yesterday, weidede arrives 26 minutes, their adversary eagle is recently 3 years come the parvenu team of the eastpart part, although never be hit into final of the eastpart part, but it is 4 strong frequenter however, result showing tremendous enthusiasm hit opponent the first times 26 than 15, established the fundamental key of the match. Eagle advocate handsome Ravi Drew says: "Showing tremendous enthusiasm is the adversary of a very difficult conquer, because no matter when, your at hand should have 3 players that can get easily 20 minutes only, wanting to win a ball is not what tickler. Wanting to win a ball is not what tickler..
4 Lian Sheng, to the 3 tycoons of showing tremendous enthusiasm, it is stitch cardiac undoubtedly, zhanmusi is to think team had found best pattern winning a ball more, he says: "We are pointing out a road that 3 people lead to a success together, help the road that team wins victory. "

Anonymous said...

Open-eyed division compares De Shuai abrupt and young flying a person adept in martial arts and given to chivalrous conduct: Won't enter the contest that buckle basket
Beijing time on March 4 message, in lake person advocate in the match with eagle of 99-98 win by a narrow margin, division comparing performed sheet to ride the performance of savior not only, still act according to went out to lie between buckle make an appointment with assorted - wonderful camera lens of Smith.
Be in after contest speak of division comparing lying between when buckling Smith, lake person advocate handsome Deandongni expresses, "Special cruel, this is the matter that he can make big money. " De Shuai say.
"It is fab really, I do not know him where do that pair of young double legs come, 4 are met finally and, he in that way unbridled ground is pounding basket basket. " De Shuai complements.
Meaning of latter charmer be gratified is contributive 1 million invite Lebulang - Zhanmusi enters the contest that buckle basket, after be surpassed with eagle the reporter also was thrown division comparing, if charmer is willing,should be asked about by the reporter he 1 million, when he can enter the contest that buckle basket again, division comparing is laughing at say, "Impossible. "Impossible..
"A few years ago, I had lain inside bier, " division comparing expresses, "Yes, I still have a lot of energy, but if you want to criticize me, say I had been finished, it is informal that that is asked. It is informal that that is asked..
In speak of oneself when the expression of last hour, division comparing expresses, "This more resembling is the information that teammate passes, want to hold fight anyhow. Want to hold fight anyhow..
To the expression of division comparing, other player also gave very big recognition. "Fortunately he (division comparing) be our team, " lay mines of lake person player overcomes say.
"This is why he (division comparing) best player. " the Huo Fude of eagle expresses.
"He is an assassin, he wants in that way hour, " the agreement of eagle team assorted - this evaluation division compares Shimisiru.
Additional, this [url=]jordans shoes for sale[/url] hopeful buckling basket that digs the Yigedala of golden team to weigh division comparing even is seleted year optimal buckle basket.
(Sohu sports: Morning morning)
More sports news

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online no prescription buy tramadol with cod - buy tramadol online reviews

Anonymous said...

The box set included 12 different workouts, a 90 day fitness plan, plus a 3 phase nutrition plan.The one thing I absolutely love about Insanity is that it enabled me to lose weight and get toned in a short period of time. [url=]cheap p90x workout[/url] It is very important to correctly breathe during the excersizes as you may pull a neck muscle like I did.And why would you discourage anyone from doing an excellent work out. [url=]p90x dvd[/url] Plus, working out on your own terms is better because you can choose to do what you enjoy and you won't feel obligated to do a work out routine you paid over 100 dollars for.The opposite thing is that it does exceed just H. [url=]cheap p90x workout[/url] I don't understand why anyone would pay that amount of money to get in better shape.Growing up, the mirror was obviously a daily reminder of my poor food choices. [url=]p90x workout dvd[/url] I don't understand why anyone would pay that amount of money to get in better shape.I'm a stay at home mom with three little kids and I had every excuse in the world why I didn't have time. [url=]p90x workout[/url] At a little scape with one of these devices your organization can be starts and cater the requirements of good number of customers.This doesn mean that you can eat Snicker bars or Reeses Peanut Butter Cups all day either.

Anonymous said...

Maybe if you had spent the money for this program it would not have taken you two years to lose the baby weight.Since buying Insanity Workout, I have been able to maintain a cardio workout for a longer period of time, my leg strength as increased, my muscle definition has increased, and I have dropped 2 pant sizes. [url=]buy insanity workout[/url] Plus, working out on your own terms is better because you can choose to do what you enjoy and you won't feel obligated to do a work out routine you paid over 100 dollars for.Maybe spending that money is the motivation they need to work out! Why you felt the need to run your baby popping mouth I can't seem to understand. [url=]buy insanity workout[/url] Who asked your opinion? But if you were just looking for some praise for you doing it with out spending money and with out the help of insanity.Maybe spending that money is the motivation they need to work out! Why you felt the need to run your baby popping mouth I can't seem to understand. [url=]buy insanity workout[/url] Insanity Workout,insanity workout On Sale For Cheap, yourwill make them cheap now.If you have back problems, joint problems, or see that P90X is actually too hard for you, you may want to reconsider the Insanity workout. [url=]insanity workout[/url] If you've ever tried the widely used P90X or Insanity workouts, you are aware that you are experiencing some of the hardest workouts ever put out on video.I have seen reviews for P90X and Insanity (both Beachbody products), and have decided to try Insanity since it seemed to offer more of what I was looking for. [url=]insanity workouts[/url] Who asked your opinion? But if you were just looking for some praise for you doing it with out spending money and with out the help of insanity.At a little scape with one of these devices your organization can be starts and cater the requirements of good number of customers.

Anonymous said...

[url=]coach factory outlet[/url] [url=]coach outlet online[/url] [url=]coach outlet online[/url] [url=]coach outlet online[/url] [url=]buy chap coach handbags[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=]cheap oakley sunglasses[/url] [url=]cheap oakley sunglasses[/url] [url=]cheap oakley sunglasses[/url] [url=]oakley sunglasses cheap[/url] [url=]cheap oakley sunglasses[/url]

Anonymous said...

The expo is different age of human civilization, is the future development of the staging area lights, is refers to the human vision of a better life.This approach was simple because it was natural and allowed the brain to adapt to increasing complexity. [url=]rosetta stone spanish[/url] Good idea in theory, however I have witnessed kids just click and click til they get the right answer.And, since Rosetta Stone automatically records your progress, you can easily pick up where you left off, when other priorities arise. [url=]rosetta stone[/url] Life needs everyone's joint effort, a man's strength is small, will be very strong accumulates.For kids who are studying a language with the goal of eventually obtaining FLUENCY (which wouldn't really be relevant to Latin, I guess) I recommend layering. [url=]rosetta stone spanish[/url] During our learning sessions we often play word games to help learn the English language and it is great fun.No doubt they are picking up vocabularythey would do that with any programso is it worth the bucks for that young? Of course they love itit's a computerized guessing game. [url=]cheap rosetta stone[/url] As children, we gradually learned our first language through a process of associating mental images with words or phrases, accompanied by complete immersion in our environment.Anytime, anywhere, you can learn a new language with Rosetta Stone. [url=]rosetta stone spanish[/url] they do this because their little ones are still in the early stages of learning to read and write their OWN languageit can be confusing to be exposed to a new set of phonics.Meet up New People By means of Joinin .